上 38 special vs 357 magnum stopping power 385505-What has more stopping power 9mm or 357 magnum
· One could argue reasonably that all a person really needs is a 357 magnum revolver with a 4inch or 6inch barrel Loaded with 38 Special rounds, it can be used for target practice and occasional, opportunistic smallgame hunting With 38 P or 357 loads, it can be used for selfdefense and hunting game up to the size of whitetails · The 357 Magnum was the result of Keith's desire to improve the power of the 38 Special cartridge I have fired the 38 Special extensively and it's my favorite handgun cartridge Keith pushed the 38 Special very hard with what was available in his day, but he wanted to go beyond those limitsI find enough problems with 357 mag 40 S&W 10mm and 45 (though to be honest that round has worked for everyone I
357 Magnum Vs 38 Special Difference And Comparison Diffen
What has more stopping power 9mm or 357 magnum
What has more stopping power 9mm or 357 magnum- · The 357 magnum is a much more powerful round than 38 special p I'd opt for the 357 magnum if in a 4" barrel as you can have the best of both worlds;Our ballistic gelatin test results for 38 Special and 357 Magnum selfdefense revolver ammoView the full test results on our interactive chart
38 Special Vs 357 Magnum The Lodge At Ammotogo Com
· 76Highboy said 357 Magnum is superior to the 44 special in terms of more stopping power for self defense The only reason the 357 Magnum is not a preferred cartridge to a semiauto pistol is ammo capacity Highboy · The 357 Magnum is the cooperative effort of forwardthinkers and cartridge architects Dan Wesson, firearms legend Elmer Keith, and author and ballistician Phil Sharpe The 357 is an elongated version of the 38 Special, designed to be used in heavierframe revolvers such as the S&W N frame · 38 Special # of people shot 199 # of hits 373 357 (both magnum and Sig) # of people shot 105 # of hits 179 % of hits that were fatal 34% It is only the fact that some guns can be fired faster than others that causes the perceived difference in stopping power If a person takes an average of 5 seconds to stop after being hit
38 Special vs 357 Magnum Since more of the bullet's mass is outside the cartridge, there is more room for powder in the cartridge The 158grain semijacketed soft point bullet permits quicker transfer of energy, which enables the bullet to do more damage · Despite having a different case length, the 38 Special is similar to the 38 Long Colt and 357 Magnum This means a 38 Special round can be safely used in revolvers with a 357 Magnum chamber and 38 Specialchambered 38 Long Colt revolvers However, a 357 cartridge will not usually fire in handguns specifically made for a 38 Special · Energy Furthermore, the muzzle energy of a 32 H&R Magnum round averages out to 0 ftlb, while a 38 Special round averages out to about 240 ftlb One way to think about this is as such a footpound is a unit of energy equal to the amount of energy required to raise a weight of one pound a distance of one foot
· My instructor was a die hard revolver guy who said you should buy a 357 magnum this way you have the option of standard 38,38P,or 357 MagnumThat being said you should get the 357Reading about the evolution of 38 special ammo from marginal stopping power with thru and thru wounds with standard 158 grain lead round nosed to the hollow points · Skip to comments THE STOPPING POWER OF DIFFERENT HANDGUN CARTRIDGES 2/22/03 Posted on 02/22/03 422 PM PST by 2nd_Amendment_Defender General Julian Hatcher, a noted forensic pathologist, in the early 1900's developed a good formula to determine the theoretical stopping power of a firearm cartridgeAfter all, it was used to protect police officers and citizens through most of the th century
An Alternate Look At Handgun Stopping Power Buckeye Firearms Association
Pin On Survival
· Moving up to 250 gr bullets we see a velocity of 1186 for 780 foot pounds in the 357 The 44 special on the other hand will give you 1032 for 591 foot pounds Now the 357 typically gets loaded with lighter rounds, as it is a smaller diameter · Facts are facts; · Word to the wise all handgun cartridges (with the likely exception of 44 Magnum and maybe even 357 Magnum) are "underpowered" for selfdefense In terms of the best "stopping power" for 38 Special, I personally like 150 grain full wadcutters or 158 grain hollowpoint semiwadcutters Both are excellent fight stoppers
357 Magnum Vs 9mm For Concealed Carry
357 Sig Vs 357 Magnum A Caliber Comparison
· Comparing loads side by side shows that 357 Magnum still has tremendous advantage in muzzle velocity over a 38 Special P if loaded by the same factory For example, the Hornady Critical Defense 38 Special P is pushing a 110 grain bullet at a stated velocity of 1090 FPS, which would produce 290 foot pounds of energy Just a note on energy – since "stopping · Stopping power scratch It is an intangible Penetration, expansion and bullet placement all lead to stopping power I suppose A 22 in the eye will have more stopping power than a 357 in the thigh There have been documented police shootings where 6 rounds of 357 were fired into the chest of the BG who kept coming · After all, it started as a black powder cartridge, which meant that the MAP had to be kept low when it was loaded with smokeless powder to prevent failure in BPera revolvers But in the 1930's, Elmer Keith and S&W loaded the 38 Special to near357 power levels in the S&W 38/44 revolver before there was a 357 Magnum
Handgun Calibers Complete Guide For Pistols And Revolvers Gearzo
Comparing Handgun Calibers Www Nstic Us
· Testing results with similar bullet sizes showed that the357 Magnum rounds produced more than twice the energy that their38 Special counterpart did Trajectory– this is an even easier comparison because the trajectory of the bullet is directly related to the velocity The357 Magnum rounds produce much flatter trajectoriesTesting everything one can think of when it comes to the difference in a 357 Magnum snub nose revolver when it comes to using 38 SpecialP or using 357 Ma · The 38 Special remains a powerful and effective selfdefense cartridge, but many people prefer the undebatable stopping power of the 357 Magnum Don't forget, however, that the 38 Special is certainly a capable round;
38 Special Vs 357 Magnum The Lodge At Ammotogo Com
357 Magnum Vs 44 Magnum Youtube
The most commonly recommended calibers for concealed carry are 380 ACP, 9mm Luger, 38 Special, 357 Magnum, 40 S&W and 45 ACP These are also respectable choices for home defense Obviously, more powerful calibers are preferable to the rimfire 22's for personal protection I included the rimfires on the list above, because they are so commonThe 38 Special cartridge, a lengthened 38 Long Colt cartridge case, was designed in 18 to be more powerful than that 38 cartridge it eventually replaced It was in turn superseded in 1934 by the 357 Magnum cartridge, which was itself more powerful, using a lengthened (by 010″) 38 Special cartridge case · Stopping Power Stopping Power 38 special or 327 federal magnum New Topic Reply to Topic Printer Friendly I will stick with the 38 special and the 357 magnum because they are street proven rounds and are available almost any where I can get them both in quantity the major sporting goods stores here don't stock the 327 fed magnum and
Medium Bore Match Up 38 Special Vs 9mm
357 Mag Vs 9mm Cartridge Comparison Sniper Country
38 Special P ammo is marginally more effective than 38 Special, and 357 Magnum loads are substantially more effective, even when fired from short barrelsThe 38 Special was designed and entered production in 18 as an improvement over the 38 Long Colt which, as a military service cartridge, was found to have inadequate stopping power against the charges of Filipino Muslim warriors during the Philippine–American War Upon its introduction, the 38 Special was originally loaded with black powder, but the cartridge's · As you can see from these paper ballistics comparisons, the 357 Magnum with a host of standard loads is considerably more powerful on paper than the 38 Special, even with a selection of P loads The 357 Magnum generally eclipses the 38P loads by nearly double in terms of muzzle energy
Does 357 Caliber Ammunition Have More Stopping Power Than 38 Cal Ammo Quora
Does 357 Caliber Ammunition Have More Stopping Power Than 38 Cal Ammo Quora
· That is to say, 357 Magnum bullets travel 15 times the speed of a 737 airplane at cruising speed, while 38 Special bullets travel 1 times that same speed Various calibers Energy Furthermore, the muzzle energy of a 357 Magnum round averages out to 530 ftlb, while a 38 Special round averages out to about 240 ftlbThe 38 Special and 9mm are the same size bullet as far as I am concerned Yes, the same size They are within two thousandths of an inch of each other The 38 Special measures 357" in diameter The 9mm measures 355" in diameter The slight difference in diameter is not relevant to any degree worth debating · The 38 Special is the round of choice in the everpopular S&W Jframe snub nose revolver, which has proven itself time and time again as both a primary sidearm and a backup or deep concealment piece A 357 needs to be somewhat heavier if the
357 Mag Ammo Arizonagunowners Com
Shooting Illustrated Snubbie Ballistics 38 Special Vs 357 Magnum
· 9mm vs 38 Special – Conceal and Carry A great number of you reading this might be considering a conceal and carry weapon Plus, you might not have made your mind up about whether to get a pistol or revolver Well, we argue that the 38 Special is still a super relevant caliber today And, this is mainly due to the type of guns that chamber it · But the 357 Magnum is sort of like the 40 S&W now it doesn't really offer enough of a performance upgrade out of a service sized handgun to be worth the extra muzzle blast and recoil you get for it If I'm going to carry a wheelgun, it's going to have 38 Special P loaded in it Modern 38 Special loads have come a long way since the 1980s · Stopping Power Stopping Power 32 vs 380 vs 38 vs 9mm New Topic Reply to Topic Printer Friendly Author Topic yrusik I would assume that the 38 Special and the 9mm are equal but how do the little rounds measure up?
357 Buster Ruger S 327 Sp101 Delivers Magnum Force Extra Firepower Gunsamerica Digest
Snub Nose Ballistics
The 38 Special rounds can be fired from revolvers chambered for 357 Magnum or the 38 Long Colt as only the case length of 38 Special is different But a 357 Magnum is more powerful and cannot be fired in a revolver chambered for 38 Special The 9mm Luger was designed by George Luger from his earlier 765X21mm Parabellum · One great advantage to the 357 (and one alluded to above) is that shooters (and beginning shooters) can practice with lighter, cheaper 38 Specials, while there isThree distinct power levels using the same bullets and all three cartridges can be fired from any357 Magnum revolver The cases are dimensionally identical, except that the Magnum case is 0135" longer than the Special case This prevents357 Magnum cartridges from entering a38 Special chamber,
38 Special And 357 Magnum Self Defense Ammo Ballistics Test Luckygunner Com Labs
357 Magnum Vs 44 Magnum Lever Actions Lucky Gunner Lounge
You can fire either 38 special, or p and 357 magnum at your discretion I don't have a problem with the 38 special load however, it does the job well and has for the past 60 years/07/05 · It was well received, with the differences in 22 Long Rifle,38 Special,357 Magnum and 44 Magnum penetration clearly demonstrated Those were different days Pine boards measured only one criteria penetration Penetration remains as · The velocity of 38 Special and 357 Magnum can be highly dependent on barrel length, so we wanted to test the two most common barrel lengths for defensive revolvers For more on why we chose these specific test guns, read our post on how barrel length affects the velocity of revolver ammo38 Special vs 357 Magnum
38 Special Vs 9mm What Does Each Caliber Offer
357 Magnum Vs 9mm
The accuracy, manageable recoil, and the ability to fire it in a357 Magnum designated gun are some of the reasons the38 Special is still popular It's always a viable round for selfdefense, but the357 Magnum may present a better option due to its stopping powerIn this video, I compare the 38 Special and the 357 Magnum Both rounds have extensive history in America, and have been around for more the 150 years com · I had checked to make sure the gun was loaded before shooting it but had not removed a bullet I assumed they were hand load 38 specials Perhaps they were anemic I went to my bullet shop and got a box of 357 mags When I opened the cylinder it was already loaded with Hornady 158 g 357 hollowpoint mags I returned with my 308 deer rifle
38 Special Vs 357 Magnum The Lodge At Ammotogo Com
Shooting Illustrated Snubbie Ballistics 38 Special Vs 357 Magnum
· 357 will offer you more versatility, but 38 is much more common Also, you won't have excessive muzzle blast issues with the 38 As far as power goes 38 Spl < 9mm < 38 P < 357 Magnum If I had a choice, I would choose a gun in 357 magnum However, I wouldn't sweat it if it was 38 only · Energy Furthermore, the muzzle energy of a 327 Federal Magnum round averages out to 450 ftlb, while a 38 Special round averages out to about 240 ftlb One way to think about this is as such a footpound is a unit of energy equal to the amount of energy required to raise a weight of one pound a distance of one footAs the designation suggests, it is more powerful than the38 Special but less powerful than the357 Magnum The Magnum had about a 96% stopping record But, this round has a lot of recoil, blast, and penetration without the right load The P load reduces these problems a little
Practical Eschatology Muzzle Velocity Vs Barrel Length Updated And Bumped
Feed Your Revolver 38 Spl 357 Mag Ballistics Gel Test Overview Lucky Gunner Lounge
· That is to say, 357 Magnum bullets travel 15 times the speed of a 737 airplane at cruising speed, while 40 S&W bullets travel 12 times that same speed Various calibers Energy Furthermore, the muzzle energy of a 357 Magnum round averages out to 530 ftlb, while a 40 S&W round averages out to about 4 ftlb · For example, the Federal HydraShok cartridges we referenced above (124gr 9mm, 158gr 357) clearly demonstrate the difference The 9mm Luger has a muzzle velocity of 1,1 feetpersecond (fps), while the 357 Magnum touts a muzzle velocity of 1,240 fps, despite the fact that its bullet is 34 grains heavierFor this reason, some dismiss magnum rounds altogether and sing the praises of the S&W 40 round, which supposedly combines the best features of the 45 ACP and the 9mm However, others say that the lowly 22 LR has the best stopping power, since it stays in the target's body and bounces around, shredding arteries and punching holes in
38 Special And 357 Magnum Self Defense Ammo Ballistics Test Luckygunner Com Labs
357 Magnum Vs 38 Special Difference And Comparison Diffen
1
Handgun Calibers Comparison From Smallest To Largest 21
357 Mag Vs 9mm Cartridge Comparison Sniper Country
What Makes A 357 Round So Much More Powerful Than A 38 Special Quora
38 Special P Vs 357 Magnum Ballistics Gel Youtube
10mm Or 357 Mag Archive The Firing Line Forums
38 Special Ammo Los Angeles
38 Special And 357 Magnum Self Defense Ammo Ballistics Test Luckygunner Com Labs
9mm Vs 38 Special Wood Test Youtube
357 Magnum Vs 44 Magnum Lever Actions Lucky Gunner Lounge
357 Magnum Vs 38 Special
38 Special Vs 357 Magnum Head To Head Youtube
Handgun Caliber Showdown Round 1 9mm Vs 357 Sig
Caliber Comparison 9mm Vs 38 Special The Truth About Guns
7 Best 357 Magnum Revolvers Proven Stopping Power Pew Pew Tactical
357 Magnum Vs 44 Magnum Cartridge Comparison Sniper Country
357 Magnum Wikipedia
The 38 Special P Vs The 357 Magnum Alloutdoor Com
History Of 38 Special Ammo Firearms Talk
357 Magnum Stopping Power Gun Nuts Media
7 Best 357 Magnum Revolvers Proven Stopping Power Pew Pew Tactical
38 Special P Vs 357 Magnum Ballistics Gel Youtube
9mm Vs
38 Special Ballistics Chart Gunners Den
Shooting Illustrated Snubbie Ballistics 38 Special Vs 357 Magnum
1
357 Mag Vs 9mm Cartridge Comparison Sniper Country
40 Vs 357 Survivalist Forum
Shooting Illustrated Snubbie Ballistics 38 Special Vs 357 Magnum
Pistol Caliber Rifles Does The 357 Magnum Reign Supreme
Shooting Illustrated Snubbie Ballistics 38 Special Vs 357 Magnum
What S The Difference Between 357 Magnum And 38 Special Ammoforsale Com
The 38 Special Vs The 357 Mag Winchester Ammunition
Feed Your Revolver 38 Spl 357 Mag Ballistics Gel Test Overview Lucky Gunner Lounge
38 Special And 357 Magnum Self Defense Ammo Ballistics Test Luckygunner Com Labs
38 Special Vs 357 Magnum The Lodge At Ammotogo Com
Which Round For Self Defense Concealed Nation
357 Magnum Vs 10mm What S Best For Your Needs
Best 38 Special 357 Magnum For Your Revolver Shooting Safety
Shooting Illustrated Snubbie Ballistics 38 Special Vs 357 Magnum
38 Special P Vs 357 Magnum Gun Nuts Media
Handgun Caliber Vs Stopping Power
Handgun Stopping Power Myth Vs Fact
38 Special Vs 357 Magnum Head To Head Youtube
38 Special Vs 9mm What Does Each Caliber Offer
357 Magnum Vs 38 Special Vs Sheet Metal Youtube
357 Magnum Vs 44 Magnum What S Better For You
State Your Case 357 Magnum Vs 44 Magnum The Truth About Guns
10mm Auto Vs 357 Magnum Video The Truth About Guns
357 Magnum Vs 44 Magnum Cartridge Comparison Sniper Country
9mm Vs 40 S W Vs 45 Acp Stopping Power Abe S Gun Cave
357 Magnum Vs 44 Magnum What S Better For You
357 Magnum Vs 38 Special
10mm Auto Vs 357 Magnum Ammunition Ballistic Test Results Video
Pistol Calibers Comparison Of The Most Common Options Cedar Mill Fine Firearms
Pin On Brief History Of 10 Mm Ammo
Handgun Calibers Definitive Guide Videos Pew Pew Tactical
Ammo 357 Magnum Vs 38 Special Comparison Uscca Blog
Can You Load A 38 Special Gun With 357 Mag Ammo Two Common Shemaugh Ties Youtube
Reload Data For 357 Mag P
God Guns And Grits 38 Special Vs 44 Special Vs 327 Magnum Look At The Numbers
Different Ammo In The Same Gun Kaboom Pew Pew Tactical
9mm Vs 38 Special Ballistics 101
Medium Bore Match Up 38 Special Vs 9mm
1
357 Magnum Vs 9mm
1
38 Special Vs 357 Magnum The Lodge At Ammotogo Com
357 Sig Vs 40 S W Caliber Comparison History And Performance
Practical Eschatology Muzzle Velocity Vs Barrel Length Updated And Bumped
Concealed Carry Ballistics Challenging The Stopping Power Conventional Wisdom The Truth About Guns
357 Vs 5 56 In Carbine Barrel 16 5 19 Survivalist Forum
What S The Difference Between 357 Magnum And 38 Special Ammoforsale Com
357 Magnum Vs 44 Magnum A Head To Head Comparison
357 Magnum Vs 38 Special Difference And Comparison Diffen
Shooting Illustrated Snubbie Ballistics 38 Special Vs 357 Magnum
38 Special Vs 357 Magnum The Lodge At Ammotogo Com
The 38 Special Vs The 357 Mag Winchester Ammunition
コメント
コメントを投稿